1 — ListenHear the debate
Each episode argues a case from two directions: the evidence, and the gut read.
2 — LookOpen the file
See what they were arguing over: the scene, the objects, the paperwork, the dates.
3 — DecideMake your own call
Nobody wins on the show. Weigh both readings and reach your own verdict.
Latest case file
Episode 16 · Updated each Sunday
Open CaseBloomfield Township, Michigan · 1975
The Disappearance of Jimmy Hoffa
The most powerful labor leader in America left home for a lunch meeting on July 30, 1975, and was never seen again. No one has ever been charged.
Open the case file →
Coming Sunday ·
Episode 17The Circleville Letters
Circleville, Ohio, 1977. A school bus driver starts getting anonymous letters. Eli follows the handwriting. Simone follows the person.
All cases
16 episodes · 16 case files open
The Sunday email
A new case every Sunday
One short email when each new case file opens. Unsubscribe any time.