February 22 – May 3, 1946 · Texarkana, Texas and Arkansas
The Town That Dreaded Sundown
Between February 22 and May 3, 1946, four attacks in and around Texarkana left five people dead and three wounded. Three took place on lovers' lanes. The fourth came through a closed farmhouse window, with a different gun. A tan work shirt found among a car thief's belongings and a 21-year-old wife who accused him and took it back are the heart of the case against him. The hosts split on whether the farmhouse was ever the Phantom's.
ELIJuly 15th, 1946. A tan work shirt is lying on a bench at the FBI laboratory. Nobody's interested in the front of it. The examiner takes a blade and opens both pockets along the seams.
SIMONEThe seams? Why the seams?
ELIBecause that's where a pocket keeps things, Simone. Whatever's been in there gets worked down into the stitching and stays. Even through the wash, and what's in this stitching is sand, tiny balls of metal slag, the kind that jump to a magnet, and hair, brown, human.
SIMONEAnd that's not even the question they sent it in with.
ELINo, the question is on the collar. There's a name written inside the neckband, faded, half rubbed away, and the lab is asked, and this is the FBI's wording, to endeavor to definitely determine whether that name is Stark or Star.
SIMONEOne letter.
ELIOne letter. A K or an R.
SIMONEAnd if it's a K, a man named Starks was shot dead in his own home that May, and this shirt turned up in another man's room.
ELIAnd if it's an R, it's somebody's laundry.
SIMONESo what did the lab say, Eli?
ELIThat's the whole episode.

The lovers' lanes
Texarkana is one town laid across two states, half in Texas and half in Arkansas. On February 22, 1946, a masked man in a hood walked up to a couple parked on a back road outside town. He hit Jimmy Hollis over the head with a pistol hard enough to fracture his skull and attacked Mary Jeanne Larey. Both survived. Nobody connected it to anything else yet.
- The townOne town across two states, Texarkana, Texas, and Texarkana, Arkansas
- The attacksFour attacks between February 22 and May 3, 1946: five people dead, three wounded
- The nameTexarkana Gazette editors began calling the attacker “the Phantom” in mid-April, after the third attack
- The panicBy May 5, forty-seven officers were working the case, and stores sold out of locks, guns and window coverings within a day
SIMONEAn editor's idea. Hold on to that, Eli, because once there's a name, there's one man. Nobody's shown that yet. The headline just assumes it. Then, May 3rd, a little before nine at night. A farmhouse about 10 miles northeast of town. Virgil Starks is 37. He farms and he runs a welding shop, and he's in his chair, reading. There's a window behind him. It's closed. Two shots through the glass, into the back of his head. His wife Katie comes in from the other room to see what broke. Two more, through the same window, into her face.
ELIAnd she gets up?
SIMONEShe gets up. She gets out of that house barefoot and makes it to a neighbor's. The sheriff questions her in the operating room. Now look at what that is, Eli. It isn't a parked car. It isn't a couple on a date. Nobody's ordered out. Nobody's touched. He fires through a closed window. And it's a .22, where it had been a .32.
ELIA different gun.
SIMONEA different everything. That's not the man in the hood. That man wants to be close. He wants them looking at him.

- 01 / 04 · MARCH AND APRIL, THE LANES
On March 24, 1946, Richard Griffin, 29, and Polly Ann Moore, 17, were found shot dead in Griffin’s car on a lane off Highway 67, each shot once in the back of the head with a .32-caliber pistol. On April 14, Betty Jo Booker, 15, left a dance at the VFW club with Paul Martin about 1:30 a.m. Martin was found shot dead at about 6:30 a.m., and Booker about five hours later, roughly two miles away. The same .32 pistol was used in both double killings.
- 02 / 04 · MAY 3, THE FARMHOUSE
Shortly before 9 p.m., Virgil Starks, 37, who farmed and ran a welding shop, was shot twice in the back of the head through a closed window of his farmhouse while he sat reading. His wife, Katie, came to see what had happened and was shot twice in the face through the same window. She survived and reached a neighbor’s house on foot. The weapon was a .22, not a .32. The FBI Laboratory concluded the cartridge cases came from “an auto loading weapon similar to the caliber .22 Colt Woodsman pistol.”
- 03 / 04 · THE SHIRT
After Peggy Swinney’s arrest on June 28, 1946, an FBI agent and an Arkansas state police officer searched the couple’s lodging and found a tan work shirt. At the FBI Laboratory on July 15, an examiner slit open the pockets and found sand, magnetic slag balls and brown human hair in the seams, and was asked whether the faded name inside the collar read STARK or STARR. The laboratory could not say how long the name had been there. It called the slag “very significant” but said the sand comparison would “probably carry very little weight.” Some of the hair was similar to Virgil Starks’s and “could not have come from the suspect.”
- 04 / 04 · PEGGY SWINNEY’S STATEMENTS
Peggy Swinney, 21, was questioned by at least a dozen officers, by the FBI’s count. On July 25 she told the sheriff she was with Youell Swinney when he killed Martin and Booker, and she signed a statement on July 26. On July 28 she said the story was untrue and that she had made it because she had been “questioned so extensively.” She signed another statement on February 19, 1947, and wrote her parents the same day that Swinney “was not the one.” The FBI agents wrote that it was hard to see how she knew what she knew unless she had been there, and also that she might have picked it up from the officers who had questioned her.
ELICan I complicate the gun?
SIMONEYou're going to anyway.
ELIThe story everybody tells is that the farmhouse was a rifle. The county sheriff said so at the time, according to Michael Newton's book on the case. But the FBI lab looked at the shell casings, and their report says they came from, quote, an auto-loading weapon similar to the caliber .22 Colt Woodsman pistol.
SIMONEA pistol?
ELIA Colt-type automatic pistol. The Lovers' Lanes were a pistol too. Smaller caliber, same general kind of weapon.
SIMONEOkay, I'll give you that. I wanted the rifle. A rifle from the tree line is a different animal. A pistol at a window is closer than I'd like.
ELIThank you.
SIMONEIt's still a window, Eli. He's still standing outside in the dark shooting a man who's reading.
ELIAnd a psychiatrist at the federal prison there said that week, in the local paper, that it was the same man. His reasoning, as Presley and Newton both report it, was that the killer knew every back road was crawling with police by then, so he'd go somewhere nobody was watching.
SIMONEOr the whole county was so wound up that any gunshot within 50 miles was going to be the Phantom's. Within a day, the stores had sold out of locks and guns and window shades. 47 officers on it. You think that town was sorting crimes carefully? And look at the paperwork. According to Michael Newton, some Texas Ranger documents listing the Phantom's victims leave the Starks' case off.
One Phantom, or two
Same caseThe FBI’s own file ties the attacks together, and the shirt belongs in it.
Eli reads the file as one killer. He gives up two things along the way: the farmhouse weapon was a pistol, not the rifle most tellings say, and the slag does not say the shirt came from Starks’s shop, only that it came from welding or grinding. What he keeps is the shirt, with hair in its seams that was similar to Virgil Starks’s and could not have come from Swinney, and a witness who walked investigators to a spot she could hardly have known. He says he cannot unhear where she took them.
The town had one label, and stuck it on two different crimes.
Simone reads the farmhouse as its own crime: a different gun, a married couple at home, shot through a window, and a town so frightened that any gunshot within fifty miles was going to be the Phantom’s. She gives up the idea that the shirt can be explained away, saying she cannot explain how hair like Virgil Starks’s ended up in the pocket of a shirt in Swinney’s room. She does not call Peggy a liar. She says a frightened 21-year-old asked the same question a dozen ways will eventually give the answer wanted.
Whether Youell Swinney was the Phantom has never been established. He was never charged with the murders and denied them until his death in 1994. Sources disagree on whether one person committed all four attacks. The shirt’s collar name could not be settled as STARK or STARR. Katie Starks first said the shirt was her husband’s, then said she could not be sure. Peggy Swinney’s fingerprints, like her husband’s, were compared with the latent prints without an identification. The 1948 suicide note of H.B. Tennison confessing to the Martin–Booker and Starks killings was not corroborated.
ELIThe slag, though. The slag in those seams is the same as—
SIMONEA welding shop's. Yes. The slag matched a welding shop.
ELINo. And this one's on me, because that's the line everybody repeats and I'd have repeated it too. The slag matched the shop. I went back to the report. It doesn't say that.
SIMONEWhat does it say?
ELIIt says the slag is the kind you get from grinding and welding. Any welding. And on the sand, which is the part you could actually compare, it says there were differences that prevent saying in court that the specimens could have come from the same source. It says the comparison would probably carry very little weight.
SIMONESo, it's a welder's shirt.
ELIIt's a welder's shirt. It is not proven to be that welder's shirt.
SIMONEShe's 21. On June 28th, she marries Youell Swinney in Shreveport, Louisiana. That same day, she's back in Texarkana walking up to a stolen car, and she's arrested. Her wedding day. And by the FBI's own count, before it's over, she's been questioned by at least a dozen officers. A dozen men, one after another. About five murders. And on the night of July 25th, she tells the sheriff she was there. She was in the car when Youell killed Paul Martin and Betty Jo Booker. She signs it the next day.
ELIAnd she shows them a place. She takes them to where she says he changed out of his bloody clothes. And the FBI teletype says that spot is the same point where the Martin boys' address book was found.
SIMONEAnd that wasn't public?
ELIAccording to Presley, the sheriff had found that book himself and kept it quiet. So how does she know?
SIMONEI'll tell you how she might. Two days later, July 28th. Two sheriffs put her in the back of a car and drive her to Dallas to show them where the clothes were burned. Two men up front, a 21-year-old behind them, a signed statement two days old. And somewhere on that road, she says none of it is true. The whole story. She says she said it because she'd been, quote, Questioned so extensively.
ELIAnd the Texas officers believed the retraction. The file says they were convinced her statement was untrue.
From the first lane to the last denial
1946 to 1994- A hooded man attacks Jimmy Hollis and Mary Jeanne Larey on a back road. Both survive.
- Richard Griffin, 29, and Polly Ann Moore, 17, are found shot dead in Griffin’s car on a lane off Highway 67.
- Paul Martin and Betty Jo Booker, 15, are killed. The bullets match the March shootings. The newspaper’s “Phantom” name follows.
- Virgil Starks is shot through his farmhouse window. His wife, Katie, survives. The weapon is a .22.
- Peggy Swinney is arrested on her wedding day. A tan shirt is found among the couple’s things and reaches the FBI Laboratory on July 15.
- Peggy tells the sheriff she was with her husband when Martin and Booker were killed, signs a statement, then says it was untrue.
- Youell Swinney is sentenced to life as a habitual criminal on a car-theft charge, and is never charged with the murders. Peggy signs a new statement on Feb. 19.
- H.B. Tennison dies by suicide in 1948, leaving a note confessing. Swinney is released in 1973 and dies in 1994, still denying it.
Two readings
No winner“I've given up the sentence I walked in with. I haven't given up the shirt.”
- “Can I complicate the gun?”
- “It's a welder's shirt. It is not proven to be that welder's shirt.”
- “I think she was there. I think you don't walk to that spot by accident.”
“I don't think the town had one phantom. I think it had one label, and the town stuck it on 2 different crimes.”
- “It's still a window, Eli.”
- “I can't tell you how hair like Virgil Starks's gets sewn into the pocket of a shirt in Swinney's room. I don't have a story for that.”
- “That's what this case does. It hands you one, and it takes it back.”
In their own words, from Episode 18.
No verdict.
SIMONEFebruary 19th, 1947. She signs a brand new statement. Her parents are sitting in the room. And that same day, Eli, the same day, she writes them a letter from the jail. The jail intercepts it. She tells her mother and father the officers will believe a lie and that Youell, her words, was not the one. She signs it, and she takes it back by mail. So which one is Peggy? The girl who knew where the address book was, or the girl writing home?
ELIThe agents who took that statement asked themselves the same thing. They wrote that it was hard to see how she could know what she knew unless she'd been there.
SIMONEAnd in the very same paragraph?
ELIIn the same paragraph, that a dozen officers had interviewed her, and it was possible she'd picked it up from them.
SIMONESo even the FBI couldn't pick.
ELII think she was there. I think you don't walk to that spot by accident.
SIMONEAnd I think if you ask a frightened 21-year-old the same question a dozen ways, she will eventually give you the answer you came for and then spend a year trying to give it back. I'm not calling her a liar. I don't think you are either.
ELINo, I'm not calling her anything. I'm saying I can't unhear where she walked them.
- If the farmhouse killing used a different gun and a different method, does it belong on the same list as the lovers' lanes?
- How much should a statement weigh when the witness took it back more than once, and the agents who took it said she may have learned the details from them?
- If a collar name could be read as STARK or as STARR, what can the shirt prove?
Hear the whole debate
A new case every Sunday
One short email when each new case file opens. Unsubscribe any time.