Eli MarchettiEli Marchetti
Simone ValdezSimone Valdez
Case files

Precision&Instinct

Debate. No verdict.

Every case Eli and Simone debate, laid out so you can look for yourself.

SCROLL  ↓
1 — ListenHear the debate

Each episode argues a case from two directions: the evidence, and the gut read.

2 — LookOpen the file

See what they were arguing over: the scene, the objects, the paperwork, the dates.

3 — DecideMake your own call

Nobody wins on the show. Weigh both readings and reach your own verdict.

Latest case file

Episode 19 · Updated each Sunday
Animated: a weathered wooden lodge at dusk beside a misty lake with one amber window glowing
UnresolvedDeep Creek Lake, Maryland and New York City · 1953

The Mysterious Death of Frank Olson: CIA, LSD, and a Hotel Window

In 1953 the CIA secretly dosed a bottle of Cointreau with LSD. Nine days later Army scientist Frank Olson went through a New York hotel window, and no one has ever been charged.

Open the case file →

All cases

19 episodes · 19 case files open
EP 01The Somerton ManCase 01 · 1948 · UnsolvedOpen the case file →
EP 02The Real ExorcistCase 02 · 1949 · DisputedOpen the case file →
EP 03The Springfield ThreeCase 03 · 1992 · UnsolvedOpen the case file →
EP 04The Black DahliaCase 04 · 1947 · UnsolvedOpen the case file →
EP 05The Boy in the BoxCase 05 · 1957 · UnsolvedOpen the case file →
EP 06Pancho Villa: The Parral AmbushCase 06 · 1923 · UnsolvedOpen the case file →
EP 07The Typewriter & The Execution of Ethel RosenbergCase 07 · 1953 · ContestedOpen the case file →
EP 08Bruno Llambrich: Le Prédateur des BoisCase 08 · 1998–2026 · DevelopingOpen the case file →
EP 09The Mad Butcher of Kingsbury RunCase 09 · 1934–2026 · Open CaseOpen the case file →
EP 10The Death of Dag HammarskjöldCase 10 · 1961–2026 · Open InvestigationOpen the case file →
EP 11The Confessions of Mack Ray EdwardsCase 11 · 1953–2011 · Unresolved ClaimsOpen the case file →
EP 12Spy in a Bag: The Death of Gareth WilliamsCase 12 · 2010 · UnsolvedOpen the case file →
EP 13The Mad Gasser of MattoonCase 13 · 1944 · UnsolvedOpen the case file →
EP 14The Hall–Mills MurdersCase 14 · 1922–1926 · UnsolvedOpen the case file →
EP 15The Chicago Tylenol MurdersCase 15 · 1982 · Open CaseOpen the case file →
EP 16The Disappearance of Jimmy HoffaCase 16 · 1975 · Open CaseOpen the case file →
EP 17The Circleville LettersCase 17 · 1977–1994 · UnresolvedOpen the case file →
EP 18The Town That Dreaded SundownCase 18 · 1946 · UnresolvedOpen the case file →
EP 19The Mysterious Death of Frank Olson: CIA, LSD, and a Hotel WindowCase 19 · 1953 · UnresolvedOpen the case file →
Support the show